Why Is User-Generated Content (UGC) So Important For Premium Brands?

User-generated content (UGC) is everywhere. It’s real, it’s raw, and it’s powerful.

But for premium brands rooted in heritage, luxury, and distinction, opening the floodgates of audience-created content may seem too chaotic to consider. 

It generates a UGC paradox.

Social proof drives trust, and consumers expect to see themselves reflected in the brands they love. This expectation puts high-end businesses under quite a bit of pressure. Every brand wants authenticity. But not at the cost of brand equity. 

UGC can be a cost-effective way to bridge this gap. But it is critical to do it in a way that protects —and ideally elevates— the brand’s identity.

From Raw to Refined: The Shift to Curated UGC

Luxury brands are flipping the UGC script. From visuals and tone to emotion and messaging, every piece of content needs to fit the brand like a glove. The days of reposting whatever content you were tagged in on Instagram are behind us. And that’s a very good thing. 

In 2024, when a TikTok video featuring a toddler joyfully yelling “ME!” in response to a question about going to Four Seasons Orlando went viral (garnering over 69 million views), the brand acted quickly. They invited the family for a complimentary stay, then turned their visit into a full-fledged branded story shared across their channels. The viral moment was transformed into a real-world expression of the luxury brand’s commitment to authentic guest connection.

It’s UGC, but with a white-glove filter. 

Behind the scenes, AI tools are making the refinement process easier. Platforms like Dash Hudson and Stackla use computer vision and machine learning to automatically tag and sort UGC based on elements like composition, lighting, color palette, and even emotional tone. Tools such as Lalaland.ai and Adobe Sensei can go a step further—evaluating whether content aligns with brand aesthetics or suggesting AI-generated alternatives if no suitable user photos are found. Some AI models even assess brand safety by flagging inappropriate backgrounds or off-brand logos. 

This level of automation helps brands maintain their high standards without manually combing through thousands of posts. But as we’ll discuss next, combining AI with UGC brings its own set of questions.

Synthetic Authenticity: AI-Generated “UGC”

Here’s where things get blurry.

Some agencies and in-house teams are skipping user-generation entirely… and going straight to AI. Think: lifestyle “selfies” that were never taken by a real person. Product reviews written by prompts. Or photos of a “creator” who doesn’t exist, wearing your newest release.

Is AI-generated UGC fast? Yes. 

On-brand? Absolutely. 

But is it authentic? 

Well, that depends on who you ask.

In June 2024, Collina Strada's collaboration with BAGGU faced significant backlash for incorporating AI-generated prints into their new collection. Consumers criticized this move, arguing that it conflicted with the brands' sustainable ethos and undermined the role of human artists. The controversy led to threats of boycotts and order cancellations, with many feeling that the use of AI in this context compromised the authenticity and artistic integrity that luxury brands are expected to uphold.

This reaction offers a cautionary tale for brands considering AI-generated “UGC.” While Collina Strada’s controversy wasn’t directly tied to user-generated content, the core issue—audiences feeling deceived or distanced by synthetic creativity—remains the same. 

And let’s not forget the legal grey areas. AI-generated content that mimics real people or places without disclosure? That could be an intellectual property (IP) or brand reputation minefield waiting to explode. And since generative AI (gen-AI) tools are often used to create this kind of content, there’s definitely a risk for copyright infringement that brands will want to avoid.

While using synthetic UGC may be tempting, luxury brands should tread carefully. What’s fast and scalable might not be sustainable—or ethical.

Hyperlocal UGC Personalizes Premium for the Global Market

UGC can be a powerful localization tool when handled strategically. Premium brands with global reach can use curated local content to connect with audiences in a more personal way. 

For example, a high-end fashion label featuring Tokyo-based creators during a regional launch is far more likely to turn the heads of a Japanese audience. This kind of hyperlocal storytelling builds trust and relevance without compromising the brand’s global image.

Brands Sézane and By Far tapped into Xiaohongshu, a Chinese lifestyle platform powered by user-generated content, to build traction before breaking into the Chinese market. Instead of launching blind, they listened. They watched how locals talked, dressed, and styled. And by showing up with their community, they earned trust, gained feedback, and tailored their approach before ever putting up a storefront. 

It’s UGC as both market research and brand building—done right.

It’s important to remember that curation becomes even more critical when applying this strategy. Local content needs to feel true to the region while still looking and sounding like your brand. That’s a delicate balance — one that requires high editorial standards, regional insight, and tight control. Collaboration with an outside (preferably local) partner can be invaluable to avoid missteps when representing your brand in a new market.

Curation, Consent, and Control

As UGC becomes more central to your strategy, the stakes get higher. Legality, ethics, and transparency become just as important as aesthetics. In fact, when you’re positioning yourself at the top of the market, it becomes a natural part of your brand promise.

While incorporating UGC into marketing strategies, luxury brands should:

• Secure proper consent - Especially if content is used in paid campaigns. A tag is not a contract, so reels/TikTok videos created about your brand don’t belong to your brand.
• Vet for legal exposure - Check into IP rights, likeness releases, and brand safety reviews. Every time.
• Disclose AI-generated content - If you’re using synthetic creators or enhanced visuals, transparency matters.

UGC Done Right … In A Luxury Context

The truth is, UGC is one of the most powerful ways to make your brand reach your audience. You’re tapping into trusted, unbiased voices and faces in the community tied to your product and brand, leveraging their expertise, name, and reputation. This is incredibly powerful for brands to solidify their presence, enter a new market, or even explode in popularity. 

So, UGC content isn’t going anywhere, if anything, it’s becoming even more influential—but only when handled with strategy, care, and clarity.

Luxury brands can’t play by the same rules as mass-market companies. They have to be more selective, more intentional, and more protective of the brand image they’ve spent decades building.

The future isn’t about saying “no” to UGC. It’s about saying “yes” to the right UGC.

It might be time to pressure-test your UGC strategy. Are you protecting your premium image while embracing cultural relevance? Are your practices legally sound and ethically smart?

When you’re ready to have that conversation, ONWRD is here to help.

‍